Štítek: The cheapest and povered than Rotax engine

  • Rotax 912 ULS versus VW 1.2 TSI

    Rotax 912 ULS versus VW 1.2 TSI

    Rotax 912 ULS versus Škoda 1.2 TSI

    Or When Winter Asks

    Flying in winter has its unmistakable charm. Snow-covered landscapes, crisp air, the sharp sound of a propeller echoing across frozen ground. Yet this is exactly when the question arises—the one that separates romance from reality: How does a powerplant perform in temperatures below –15 °C?

    This chapter is a personal, technical, and operational comparison of two worlds—the aviation classic Rotax 912 ULS (100 HP) and the automotive conversion Škoda 1.2 TSI producing 144 HP.


    The Morning Ritual: Starting the Rotax

    Starting the Rotax 912 ULS in deep frost requires preparation. The engine is often wrapped in blankets, while a 2 kW electric heater powered by a generator warms the engine compartment. Only after 35–40 minutes is the unit ready for an attempt to start.

    A more efficient option is an 8 kW diesel heater powered by a car battery. Heating is faster, more effective, and operationally more comfortable.

    However, the standard battery frequently lacks the strength to crank the engine at the required RPM in low temperatures. And so you circle around the Rotax like a devoted servant attending a demanding master:

    “What would little Rotax like now? More choke? Less choke? A different procedure?”

    For winter operation, it is necessary to tape over part of the coolant and oil radiators—sometimes halfway, other times up to two-thirds. It depends on the outside temperature and the size of the oil cooler (the manufacturer offers three variants).

    In its basic configuration, the Rotax 912 ULS has neither a thermostat for the water circuit nor for the oil circuit. These must be addressed by the user.

    The engine weighs approximately 80 kg, and the purchase price of a used unit is around 8000 EUR. It is a proven, aviation-certified package—but winter comfort is not among its strongest qualities.


    You Arrive, You Turn, You Fly

    The Škoda 1.2 TSI behaves differently in freezing conditions. It usually fires on the second pull of the propeller—by hand. In my case, the electric starter was removed as an unnecessarily heavy component. Every true aviator should try hand-starting an engine at least once. If you know how to do it, nothing bad will happen.

    For the more cautious, there is the “behind-the-propeller” starting method, staying outside the arc of potential impact.

    The procedure is simple:

    Turn the propeller once with the ignition off to avoid hydraulic lock. Switch on the ignition. Hand-start. Warm up. Fly.

    For those who prefer comfort, an electric starter can of course be used within the conversion setup.

    The 1.2 TSI engine weighs approximately 100 kg. The base engine costs around 400 EUR, and after modifications and manufacturing a reduction drive, the total comes to about 2400 EUR if you follow my DIY manual for building the aviation conversion.

    A 20 kg weight advantage in favor of the Rotax stands here against a significant price difference—and an additional 44 horsepower.


    Carburetors versus Direct Injection

    The Rotax 912 ULS uses carburetors. Carburetor icing is addressed by:

    • an airbox with exhaust-based preheating
    • electric heating elements between the intake flange and carburetor
    • water-heated intake components

    Each of these solutions, however, reduces engine performance.

    Without preheating, the engine may run rough, jerk, and vibrate. A pilot trained to perceive sounds and vibrations immediately senses that something is wrong. He fine-tunes the propeller pitch. If “fine pitch” does not help, he applies full throttle, changes altitude, and simultaneously searches for a suitable emergency landing area—exactly as practiced many times during training.

    The 1.2 TSI engine with direct dual fuel injection, proper ignition mapping, and turbocharging does not face such issues.

    The intake air is heated as it passes through the turbocharger. The choke function is automatic—two injectors instead of one. The engine features two integrated thermostats, maintaining different temperatures for the cylinder head and engine block.

    No persuasion. No experimenting. You just fly.


    Power That Changes the Rules

    One hundred forty-four “Mustangs” under the cowling spin a two-meter propeller strongly enough to lift you off a snow-covered surface with a 13 cm frozen crust in just 42 meters—even with full tanks.

    Climb performance in icy air is astonishing. If you want to maintain the prescribed climb angle, you must reduce throttle; otherwise, you climb too fast without flaps. There is power reserve in every situation.

    Where an aircraft equipped with a Rotax 912 ULS accelerates in snow only to 40–50 km/h and goes no further, the aircraft with the 1.2 TSI is already airborne.

    The nearly sixty-year technological gap is clearly noticeable.


    Skis, Wheels, and Freedom

    Flying with skis mounted alongside wheels—where the wheels extend about 60 mm below the skis—opens entirely new possibilities.

    You take off from snow. Dozens or even hundreds of kilometers later, you land on grass where snow is almost unknown. You can even take off uphill at a very steep angle.

    This is not just technology.
    It is freedom of movement.


    And When Summer Asks?

    Extreme heat benefits neither engine.

    With the Rotax, a larger radiator with improved core design can be selected. In turbocharged versions—Rotax 914, Rotax 915 iS, and Rotax 916 iS—higher temperatures may cause detonation because the intake air is too warm and further heated by the turbocharger. These engines therefore reduce power shortly after takeoff.

    A similar situation occurs with the 1.2 TSI if the water-cooled intake radiator cannot sufficiently cool the intake air. The control unit monitors the knock sensor and reduces power at the first sign of detonation.

    Solutions?

    • Install an air-to-air intercooler
    • Use 98 or 100 octane fuel
    • Optimize the ignition map

    Final Reflection

    On paper:

    • Rotax 912 ULS – 80 kg, used one approx. 8000 EUR
    • Škoda 1.2 TSI – 100 kg, approx. 2400 EUR (when built according to the DIY manual)

    A 20 kg difference versus a 5600 EUR price gap—and 44 horsepower.

    In winter, what matters is your willingness to prepare, preheat, adjust, and adapt.

    Or your desire to arrive, turn the propeller, and fly.

    When winter asks, the answer is not purely technical.

    It is a question of flying philosophy—and the price you are willing to pay for it.

    Filip Zejda